15 Best Bay Rum Aftershave For Excellent Scent And Avoid Painful Shave 2020

shaving is not complete without best bay rum aftershave lotion. A classic post-shave fragrance that is increasingly popular today is bay rum. It is one of the oldest scents after shaving, dating from the Antilles in the sixteenth century.

Men in the 1800s and early 1900s could not imagine their daily shaving routine without aftershave with rum on the bay. I saw my father’s obsession with this when I was a kid, even applied a bit of this lotion to my face when I was only 10 or 12 years old. I know it sounds crazy, but I couldn’t wait for my beard to grow. The spicy, sensual scent of laurel was simply too irresistible.

With shaving in the wet increasingly popular and all returning to the use of safety razors, we are seeing a great comeback with the aftershave lotion.Best Bay Rum Aftershave

It is easy to see why bay rum returns in the bay. It’s old school but not old-fashioned: a masculine scent of cloves and spices.

Even so, the few companies that use authentic laurel leaves and rum will have variations in terms of odor, depending on where they get their bay leaves and rum.

Even if two companies use identical ingredients, the smell will still vary depending on their proper blends.

If you are also looking for recommendations for the best bay rum aftershave for that perfect finishing touch, you’ve come to the right place and I’ll help you find the best bay rum aftershave.

What Is The Difference Between A Bay Rum Aftershave Lotion And A Regular Post-Shave Lotion?

While these two products have the same purpose, the biggest difference between these two products would be the ingredients they contain.

A lotion for after bay rum has two main ingredients: bay leaf and rum.

Lotions for after regular use many more chemicals and are divided into two subcategories: water-based and alcohol-based.
The smell is another thing that separates these two.

The aftershaves of Bay rum have a strong aroma characterized by a wood, earthy or spicy aroma.

Types Of Aftershave

The market has a wide range of aftershave products. They generally come in four forms: creams, gels, balms, and lotions. In addition to working as an antiseptic, they also soothe, moisturize and rejuvenate dry, irritated skin after shaving. Unlike other products that you use during shaving, aftershaves have a longer effect. You do not wipe them away immediately after use.

As we mentioned earlier, lotions have the highest alcohol content of all aftershave products on the market: no less than 60 to 75%. They are very similar to the types of aftershave that hairdressers used to use. We recommend sending aftershave lotions away if you can. The high alcohol content in it not only dries out your skin but also narrows the pores and causes indirectly ingrown hairs.

Why Even Use Bay Rum Aftershave?

The main purpose of the aftershave lotion is to soothe the skin.

If you have problems cutting the skin, skin irritation, rash, and similar problems, the aftershave lotion has excellent healing properties.

Most post-shave lotions have ingredients that act as astringents to prevent cuts from bleeding. Other ingredients moisturize and soften the skin.

help with acne. If you have occasional bouts that bother you after shaving, they will help you fight that.

It helps to tighten the skin and prevents acne in this way. If acne is a major concern, you may want to opt for an alcohol-based aftershave.

15 Best Bay Rum Aftershave On The Market

The best thing about aftershave is that you can find one that is suitable for every skin type. There are many types of aftershave products on the market, making it difficult to know which one suits you best. This article discusses the 15 best bay rum aftershave based on their price range, popularity with customers and overall quality.

#PreviewProductDimensionsRating
1Bay Rum Aftershave SplashBay Rum Aftershave Splash for Men - Crafted with Authentic Bay Oils from Dominica Republic in The Virgin Islands - Natural and Pure Ingredients - 4oz. - from Barberry Coast Shave Co.3 x 3 x 6 inches ; 7 ounces
500 Customer Reviews
28 oz Genuine Ogallala8 oz Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum Regular. Old-time looking bottle and label.1 pounds
130 Customer Reviews
3Captain's Choice Original BayCaptain's Choice Original Bay Rum 4.0 oz After Shave Pour1.5 x 2 x 4 inches
328 Customer Reviews
4Clubman Pinaud Virgin IslandClubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum Cologne, 12 fl oz2 x 7.5 x 3 inches ; 12 ounces
1,172 Customer Reviews
5Gilbert Henry Bay RumGilbert Henry Bay Rum Balm: Artfully Designed and Skillfully Crafted to Earn You Compliments On Your Look and Your Choice of Fragrance.2 x 2 x 6 inches
102 Customer Reviews
6GABELS Bay Rum AfterGABELS Bay Rum After Shave Lotion 16oz/1pt
348 Customer Reviews
7Hurricane Series Bay RumHurricane Series Bay Rum (8oz.)1.1 pounds
5 Customer Reviews
8Grand Bay Bay RumGrand Bay Bay Rum Aftershave 8oz
36 Customer Reviews
9Taylor of Old BondTaylor of Old Bond Street Bay Rum Aftershave, 5 Fluid Ounce1.5 x 1.5 x 4 inches ; 5.3 ounces
16 Customer Reviews
10Royall Bayrhum Of BermudaRoyall Bayrhum Of Bermuda By Royall Fragrances For Men. All Purpose Lotion 8.0 Oz.4 x 3 x 10 inches ; 0.16 ounces
149 Customer Reviews
11DR Harris Hair LotionDR Harris Hair Lotion Oil Free (Bay Rum)
12St Johns Bay RumSt Johns Bay Rum Cologne/Aftershave Lotion 8 Oz Splash VIP Sized. The Best Smelling Fragrance for Men. Handcrafted. Bay Leaf Oils, Premium Spices in U.S.V.I. Popular Fragrance for Guys for 70 Years.1.2 pounds
110 Customer Reviews
13Well Master Comb AfterWell Master Comb After Shave Lotion 15 Oz2.5 x 2.5 x 9.2 inches ; 8 ounces
70 Customer Reviews
14Bull and Bell AftershaveBull and Bell Aftershave Tonic - Handmade in USA Using All Natural Ingredients Including Witch Hazel - 4oz - Best Aftershave for Sensitive Skin (Bay Rum)2 x 2 x 3 inches ; 4 ounces
9 Customer Reviews
15Turtle Bay Premium BayTurtle Bay Premium Bay Rum After Shave with Bay Essential Oil - 8oz Hip Flask
4 Customer Reviews
Prices/Images/Reviews pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 18/11/2019 10:04 AM

1-Bay Rum Aftershave from Barberry Coast Shave.

What I like about this product is 100% of all-natural ingredients that do not contain parabens or alcohol that can dry out the skin.
It also contains skin-friendly ingredients such as Aloe Vera, Vitamin E and shea butter.
Bay Rum Aftershave from Barberry Coast Shave 1This product will leave a cooling sensation due to the menthol content.
Barberry Coast was able to achieve this thanks to the genuine combination of oils and spices extracted from bay leaves of the West Indies.

The fragrance also comes from natural sources such as cloves, vanilla, cinnamon, orange, and allspice.

Prices/Images/Reviews pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 15/12/2019 20:10 PM

All these ingredients in addition to smelling good to have numerous benefits for our skin. These include stress relief and improves blood circulation.

If you are looking for something with a traditional smell, then this would be a great option. Keep in mind that the smell is not so strong and if you prefer something with a stronger aroma, opt for another product on this list.

Pros
  • I would recommend this thing for the natural ingredients that do not pose a threat to your skin.
  • You have this subtle scent that lingers long after you apply it to your face.
  • Glycerin keeps the moisture from your skin trapped, unlike alcohol that dries it. In addition to the fragrance, Barberry Coat provides aftershave antioxidants and stress-relieving properties.
  • The makers’ confidence shines with a 100% lifetime money-back guarantee of the product.
Cons
  • People first feel the burning sensation, so alcohol is mixed with other ingredients.

Customer Images

Bay Rum Aftershave Splash Customer Image Bay Rum Aftershave Splash Customer Image 1Bay Rum Aftershave Splash Customer Image 2

Questions & Answers

What are the ingredients?

Alcohol, glycerin, bay leaves, cinnamon, cloves, allspice, orange, vanilla and purified water. It is not on the label, but it also contains masculinity, courage, good taste and courage.

Could someone describe the scent of this? Thanks

Everyone's scent is different, but I will do my best to describe the scent. With the first application (not sniffing from the bottle) I notice the first tones on its bay leaves, allspice and cinnamon. While it dries, I smell vanilla and cloves and the cinnamon fades into the background. Then comes a light orange note while the vanilla persists. The scent of the bay and allspice remains everywhere. This is our version of laurel. We have given it a modern twist (more modern scent) while we honor the old rum from the bay. We use only the best all-natural essential oils, extracts and absolute ingredients. I hope this helps.

How long does the scent last.?

I put it on about 3 hours ago this morning and it is still noticeable.

Does this have alcohol in it?

Yes, the bottle mentions alcohol as the first ingredient.

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Bay Rum Aftershave Splash

JETPILOT

I don't know if it gets better than this! Smell is great. I have used Captain's Choice and the smell is similar but smoother. Comparing the two corresponds to the difference between a nice drinkable cognac and a VVS reserve. Like all premium products, it has a premium price. The price has cost this product review 1 star. Even at the selling price of $ 38 from the normal $ 52, it is difficult to justify the extra costs. Captain's Choice is $ 18.95 for the same size of 4 oz. You can buy two bottles of Captains Choice for the price of one bottle of Barberry Coast. I think it's great ... yes! I will buy it again for $ 38 ... maybe. Shall I buy it for $ 52 ... no.

Avatar Reviews  Bay Rum Aftershave Splash 1

Jon Farris

A very good scent. treats the skin really well after a nice shave. has a cool, calming burn and a very pleasant odor. I regularly use ogallala, dominica and captains. On my skin it smells like a more elagant nine-tailed captain's choice cat. This barberry coast has a much more balanced and full scent, with less overwhelming and remarkable tones than the captain's choice. definitely worth the price difference. the label is nice and the frosted bottle is a nice touch, looks really stylish in my range of rum rum in my portion of aftershaves. The scent stayed with me for a few hours, but not overwhelming all day, like my beloved Ogallala Bay Rum. but that's how I prefer it, I deliberately use an aftershave and don't follow it with an eau de cologne with the intentions of a nice subtle scent, and not the chemical doused cheap cologne scent of foreigners who want to wipe out an entire room on entry. What it comes down to is my sensitive skin and nose, this aftershave is top notch, and I would appreciate her scent and balanced strength as great for an aftershave.

Avatar Reviews  Bay Rum Aftershave Splash 2

Kenneth R. Young

Ok stuff. Don't burn my face like many aftershaves I've used. Has more than a hint of orange that goes well with the Laurier rum. Nice, organic scent and feeling that doesn't last long. This is my only complaint. Call me old school, but I prefer a stronger aftershave. I think if it is used up, I will order it again because I just love the smell. I wish it were stronger.

Avatar Reviews  Bay Rum Aftershave Splash 3

YpsiExplorer

I love this aftershave! I tried Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum Body Care, 6 Ounce before I tried it and I think it's a lot better. Both have a bit of an angel, but the Barberry Coast seems to hydrate better. The scent of the Barberry Coast is MUCH nicer. The scent usually smells of cloves, cinnamon and bay leaves. The Clubman had a chemical odor where the Berberish Coast smells naturally. I was a little worried that while wearing the Clubman, I would smell too much like an "old man." I'm not worried about that with the Barberry Coast. I also got a bottle with some dark spots, like another reviewer. I emailed Barberry Coast customer service and they sent me an email within hours and said it was a natural oil separation that can happen sometimes, nothing to worry about. I appreciated the quick answer! All in all, this stuff smells great, works very well and is, in my opinion, worth the price.

500 Customer Reviews

2- Genuine Ogallala: Bay Rum Aftershave

Located in the beautiful old cowboy village of Ogallala, Nebraska, the artisanal products of the authentic Ogallala Bay Rum Toiletry Company are among the best shave bottles available.

Genuine Ogallala, which probably has the strongest and most lasting smell of all the products on this list. As for the ingredients, this is another that only contains all-natural ingredients such as witch hazel, bay oil, cinnamon, clove oil, rosemary, orange, lime, ginger, sage, and wintergreen. All of these essential oils combine to give this one of the deepest perfumes of any post-shave rum we have ever encountered.On the other hand, they also create a scent that is not exactly what one imagines you should smell a laurel rum (although it is quite similar), but it is still quite pleasant.
While the smell is definitely nice, there are still some problems that prevent it from being the first on this list.

First, this product tends to dry the skin a bit more than the others on this list, since it does not contain glycerin (although witch hazel does have some excellent nutritional properties for the skin).

The other main problem is that, once again, it does not smell exactly like an aftershave rum should be. While it smells good, if you’re looking for a true rum fragrance bay rum, you might be a little disappointed.

Pros
  • The design will certainly interest people; a vintage bottle with a screw cap indicates aristocracy.
  • In my opinion, the makers simulated the organic scent of Bay Rum as closely as possible.
  • I feel that the price is exactly right. It is not too high or too low compared to the other options we have.
  • Ogallala customer service is something to cherish for our general users there.
  • Having the right amount of alcohol is the key to giving users the burning sensation.
Cons
  • The odor disappears fairly quickly after you first apply the aftershave.
  • I would have liked to keep afloat in place to keep the liquid in the bottle.

Questions & Answers

Does the bottle have a restrictor to limit the amount poured out?

Not mine. So after the alarming case of contact dermatitis that I got from this brand, it poured down the drain easily and quickly.

Is this a glass bottle?

Yes

Has anyone been able to buy a Bay Rum in a Spray container?

The Bay Rum Aftershaves and Colognes are available in 2 oz and 4 oz spray bottles.

Do the bottles in the Bonanza Sampler Pack come as miniatures of the blue 8 oz featured as a pic?

Although I did not order the bonanza package, I did place a large order directly with the company and I received some smaller bottles with different scents. They came in small versions of the 8 oz. bottles.

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  8 oz Genuine Ogallala

Jennifer Carr

I purchased this product through my wife's Amazon account. I have been using Pinaud for a while and I think Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum is a good product. It is a shortcoming because the scent fades very quickly to the point where it is imperceptible. I was looking for a product that had a bit more endurance and decided to try this Bay Rum. I had read good things about this product and one of the positives I had read was that it is slightly stronger than most Bay Rums on the market. My first impression is that the smell is clearly different from the Pinaud product. It reminded me of a seasoned lawyer with a mild clove scent. Although I will use this product until it is gone, I will not buy it again. I have just ordered a bottle of Gabels to see how it stacks up against Pinaud and will review that when I receive it. As for Ogalla ... it's good. I will certainly use it, but I will not buy it again.

Avatar Reviews  8 oz Genuine Ogallala 1

Number6

This is Bay Rum as it used to be when men were men and were not afraid of a little pain. It smells great and is a good way to complete a razor shave (or any shave). Yes, it burns, but it is not buttermilk. It is Bay Rum. After a bit it sinks into a nice warm feeling in the face, then everything is fine. Love it.

Avatar Reviews  8 oz Genuine Ogallala 2

Kenneth R. Young

Good bay rum. I use Ogallala Bay Rum and Sandalwood regularly. I love the smell and the way it feels on my skin. The normal bay rum is great. I have nothing negative to say. I prefer the bay rum and sandalwood. I get a lot of compliments when I use that.

Avatar Reviews  8 oz Genuine Ogallala 3

Amber

By far my favorite aftershave of all time, I love the vanilla and the sweet orange, cologne is great and deodorant (vanilla) the shaving soap can no longer forget vanilla and orange

130 Customer Reviews

3-Captain’s Choice Original Bay Rum AfterShave

Captain’s Choice is one of the most recommended aftershave lotions for men who love the traditional aromas of bay rum. It has a particularly strong cinnamon note and some notable notes of clove.

In 2011, Scott Brennecke was frustrated by the lack of high-quality aftershaves in the market.

He spent four frustrating months trying to perfect his bay rum before he was ready to start selling it.
This touch of bay rum is a popular choice in the wet shaving community because of the unique sensation of bite described as (perfect burn).
It is an intense burn similar to pepper but to the skin.

This feeling starts lightly and quickly becomes something that you think you can not handle.
The men who liked the sensation have described it as (addictive). It has a classic aroma of laurel rum with just a touch of clove.

So, if you do not like the nail, this is a good alternative.

Most wet shaving machines agree that Captain’s Choice Bay rum is one of the best options available after shaving with bay rum.

The aroma is not overwhelming, but it is well rounded. Unlike other bay rums, it is not dominated by the addition of cloves.

Pros
  • I liked how Cat O’Nine Tails smells. The sweet scent of sandalwood is always a welcome feature.
  • This thing is absorbed into the skin fairly quickly. Cat O’Nine Tails doesn’t even cause the yellow glow.
  • You will notice a soft and warm feeling when it starts to work its magic on your skin.
  • Witch hazel has antibacterial properties. Small incisions and cuts healed quickly in my case.
  • Glycerin is a welcome addition to the traditional ingredients of this fragrance of laurel shaving.
Cons
  • People first feel the burning sensation, so you have mixed alcohol with other ingredients.
  • The combustion it causes is also noticeable. I would not recommend it for people with sensitive skin.

Customer Images

Captain's Choice Original Bay Customer Image Captain's Choice Original Bay Customer Image 1

Questions & Answers

Does the scent of this aftershave leave before you can get out of the house???

The odor is quite weak. I prefer the California Antilles Trading Co. Dominica Bay Rum.

How does this compare to stuff like Dominica or Ogallala?

Don't think so strongly. OK for daily use. Don't know about Dominica.

Is there a large hole to pour it out or is it controled with a small hole?

It has a throttle valve under the lid

Does this have alcohol in it?

I googled it for you! captianschoicestore.com, clicked on the Bay Rum bottle and they list the ingredients !! "Alcohol, witch hazel, essential oils and extracts, glycerin." 😉

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Captain's Choice Original Bay

the rob

Sting: noneTexture: silkyClove: medium-mildBay leaf: strongStrength: mediumConstitution: weakTreated: yesMiddle-age: yesTeenagers: dependsOffice: will not disturb neighbors of the cubeBar: not effective in bar situationSummary: Excellent overall after-shave. If you are looking for an explanation, look elsewhere.

Avatar Reviews  Captain's Choice Original Bay 1

R. Ellis

This has a very rich, spicy aroma and goes smoothly - the witch hazel neutralizes the alcohol well in this Bay Rum and there is no chemical odor like some others I have tried. The scent is very spicy in the beginning and then disappears in a relatively short time - not at all overwhelming or something that you smell in the shower tomorrow. An hour after applying this I could still smell it when I held my hands over my mouth and chin, but only mildly, so it is not something that you will change to M. Gustave. but it is also not a momentary odor like citrus. If you are looking for something that is labeled "after shave", but behaves like a cologne, then this is probably not the best choice, but if you like a warm, spicy aromatherapy experience after shaving and you prefer aftershave based aftershave, you should really give this a try.

Avatar Reviews  Captain's Choice Original Bay 2

Jonathan M.

I love this bay rum! It had the buttery smell that I expected from a good aftershave of rum. You can choose a number of different scents such as the bay, vanilla, cloves, etc. My wife says it smells like Christmas. I tell her it smells of masculinity. The only down side is when my 18 year old son tries to cover his funk with it. This stuff is great, but please take a shower before you use it !!!

328 Customer Reviews

4-Clubman Pinaud Bay Rum

Clubman Pinaud bay rum smells of nostalgia from the golden age. The uber-masculine perfume with strong hints of bay leaves, cloves and cinnamon has weakened women on their knees since 1880. That is quite long!

About the fragrance profile, the first thing you touch immediately after applying the lotion is a heavenly note of cloves and cinnamon. You can only smell the bay leaves after the solution has dried on your skin.

This is one thing you should know before it drives you crazy. Unlike traditional bay rum aftershaves, it has no rum in it. It is SD-40 alcohol that causes quite a bit of burning when applied immediately after shaving. For those who don’t know, the SD-40 acts as a disinfectant for notches, cuts, and bumps after shaving.

When checking the label you may find the names of some synthetic chemicals. I just want you to know that most of these substances are derived from essential oils.

Most people who complain about severe burning or redness probably use a lot. You are supposed to use only a line on your face and body. So it is not right to fully blame the product.

If your skin is seriously allergic to synthetic fragrances or dyes, I recommend that you consult a dermatologist before using it. You can also do a patch test on your skin if that’s handy. Another glitch in the product is the lack of potency in the fragrance. Although it smells absolutely good, I wish it could have been a bit stronger and more durable.

Pros
  • Those of you who like to have a direct burn on your face while using laurel will love this thing.
  • Alcohol is a strong disinfectant, with this amount of small incisions and bruises have no chance.
  • The aftershave has a soft scent that gives you a pleasant feeling when it comes into effect.
  • I noticed five different but subtle scent layers with which this thing comes or changes.
  • The scent will not project much; perfect for guests who want their aftershave to be discreet.
Cons
  • The alcohol is intense. So, Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum is not for everyone.
  • Pinaud has included some difficult to pronounce chemicals in the mix. I would say: Buy wisely.

Customer Images

Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Customer Image Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Customer Image 1Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Customer Image 2

Questions & Answers

Is this considered a hazardous item in regards to shipping. Lisa W from customer service says it is but it is not referenced anywhere on this page.?

This item is shipped as hazardous materials. If you receive it in a place that restricts deliveries of hazardous materials, you may have a problem. However, I did not find any leakage.

What are the ingredients?

Ingredients list: SD Alcohol 40 (2%), water, fragrance, FD & C Blue 1 (CI 42090), FD & C Red 4 (CI 14700, FD & C Yellow 5 Aluminum Lake

How close is the scent to col. conk bay rum shave soap?

Very different. Colonel Conk does not smell like bay rum. It smells very ripe limes and slightly spicy. This smells like rum and nails with a touch of bay.

Is this an after-shave, cologne, or parfum??

I use it as an after-shave. It's not exactly the smell of the old hairdresser (a bit more flowery), but it's fine.

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island

Heartbreak Motor Oil

Instructions for use: frown on the mirror and wet your mug to shave. Shave as usual with an ED or a straight razor. Pour a small palm full of this in your hand, rub your hands and apply it to all shaved areas. Hit your chest with both hands, smell like a real man and scorn with contempt the types of millennial pajamas that you will chew and spit throughout the day.

Avatar Reviews  Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island 1

Jacob

I'm not kidding when I say that when the first smell of these things came to my nose, I smiled. Now, THIS is what I want to breathe all day. It is not musky, it is not fruity, it is not subway. It is not the weak "brightness of light" that most men choose unfortunately. This is splash, slap your face, awaken goodness. It smells delicious. And I'm really talking about delicious men. Pinaud Bay rum is complex, warm, woody and spicy, but not overwhelming. I have read other comments here that say "a drop behind each ear", etc. Are you kidding? I suppose that will be enough for a few minutes, but if you want to smell man, be reliable and robust all day, get a good generous touch and hit him on the cheeks and neck, and get something to defend himself from his wife or girlfriend. with. She will attack in 5 ... 4 .... 3 .... As a whiskey connoisseur, I implemented my olfactory skills to see what this brew had to offer. For the first time, of course, you get the outstanding notes: cloves and cinnamon. But after that, there are more subtle varieties that highlight the complexity of shaving in shades of vanilla, pepper, oak, maybe even leather. I could be making leather. Maybe it's the best combination of aromas that has ever adorned my nose. I'll tell you that for some years, I've been alternating between the classic Old Spice (yes, I know it's not the original recipe, so sit down) and Brut. These are pretty muscular and old, but they were good for my budget and they did the job. Also, I like the way they hit you in the face after a new shave DE. It feels more spicy when you have some nicks. One of my favorite parts about aftershave is burning after shaving. It makes me feel alive. Then, I expected the Pinaud to do the same. Dang was impressed. Not only did my generous splash sting very well, but it also left my face in a surprisingly flexible condition. Surely I did not expect the soft, semi-hydrated feel of Bay Rum. I'm used to Old Spice and Brut drying their faces right away, so I could live because I felt really good about putting on. But with Pinaud Bay rum it is the best of both worlds. There is something in the tonic that is super soft and feels refreshing and healthy for your skin. So I put on a second splash and did not look back. I could not be more satisfied with these things ... I've tried colonies (including the bay rum colony), balms and other after-shave products, but none compares to this. The Pinaud Bay rum smells of a combination of Christmas Eve, a wooden warehouse, a pirate and grandpa's barbershop. Side note: you could not care less about the plastic bottle with which people grab around 5 satisfied stars. Another generous splash? I do not care if I do it.

Avatar Reviews  Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island 2

Ed

First, it does itch. But it should, it's for after-shave alcohol-based. I am using a double-edged razor, and the Propraso shaving soap with a good badger brush. This is my daily routine after shaving, and it completes the image well. From the perspective of the scents, I prefer the aftershave after Layrite Bay, but that's just a preference. Pinaud has a great refreshing smell and feels like a good kick. As an aftershave does the trick and seals everything very well. Pinaud is as good as he is, it's just a preference from here. And remember, if you are paying much more than this, you are only wearing perfume, princess. I'm taking a point for the cheap plastic bottle. I would really like to see an option with a glass bottle, even if that means a dollar more. But in general, I have a solid option.

Avatar Reviews  Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island 3

Banzaidog

I was fascinated by the term "bay rum". I could not find it anywhere in my area, so I took a chance on this. And I'm glad I did. Some shevers are generically "spicy", but the Pinaud Bay rum has a clear pinch of cinnamon and not very sweet cloves, along with a nice note that I can not identify. I suppose it must be laurel. In any case, it is really refreshing and has become one of my favorites. Like the rest of the Pinaud line, it is a distinctive scent; not cloying, nor dominant, guaranteed that no one else around you will use it. Old School? You gamble. I have learned that there are two different schools of thought in Bay Rum. One argues that the cinnamon and clove combo makes it ideal for winter, especially during Christmas. The other holds that, because cinnamon and cloves come from lush tropical places, it is the ideal fragrance for summer. Go figure!

1,172 Customer Reviews

5-Gilbert Henry Natural Bay Rum Aftershave Balm

Although it’s not hard to find a completely natural bay rum aftershave splash, finding a really natural bay rum aftershave balm is something completely different.

But that is exactly what it is – only use natural essential oils of aromatherapy quality and are free from parabens and other unwanted chemicals.

Personally, I love to relieve pain and irritation afterward less than stellar shaves thanks to the aloe-based, which hydrates and soothes the skin without leaving a greasy or oily residue.

Another reason I prefer is that it actually contains no alcohol (alcohol is on) the ingredient list, but the company says this is because some extracts are made with alcohol), which means it has won) Don’t dry out your skin like so many other products.

Of course, the lack of alcohol probably means that it doesn’t really deserve the rum label on the bay, but the smell is still exactly what you would expect.

Prices/Images/Reviews pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 16/12/2019 04:05 AM

That said, although I and many others really like the smell of this specific product, it has a much stronger clove smell than many other products – with quite a few reviewers that the smell of clove was a bit too overwhelming.

Pros
  • I think it’s great to have a pump cap. Amateurs and first-timers will not spill too much of the aftershave.
  • You have citrus, authentic West Indian bay leaf and allspice with clove and sandalwood base.
  • I liked the addition of Neem oil and witch hazel. The makers insisted on healing notches and cuts.
  • The formula contains no synthetic elements. This makes it free of parabens and sulfates.
  • I liked how light it feels in my hands. It doesn’t feel greasy! Even for a second or two.
Cons
  • I would find the price steeper than the others in the same category.

Questions & Answers

Is this product alcohol free?

It is not alcohol-free. Alcohol is one of the last mentioned ingredients. I think it is an excellent after-shave product. It is very soothing for the skin and leaves no greasy residue. Give it a try!

How is this for beard or hair? Example, while rinsing hands after shave or beard trim. Thx

I wear a gotee and it is no problem if I rub it in the skin before I take care of my mustache and gotee.

I thought I bought this when it delivered to Canada, but the bottle was square shaped - is this the same product?

My bottle was round. Probably just new packaging

Does this contain alcohol? And if it does, does it have a burning sensation after applying?

The product says no alcohol-free (as their Bay Rum Aftershave Balm does), but I don't experience any burns when I apply it immediately after shaving. The company offers a trial size of the product on their website, if you want to try it with less investment.

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Gilbert Henry Bay Rum

Pagasman

I love the smell of bay rum and I was really looking forward to trying this aftershave balm. I found the all-natural ingredients very attractive and the glowing reviews made me excited to order it. As soon as I received this balm, I used it the next morning. It is not greasy at all and continues very nicely with no residue. HOWEVER, the clove smell is overwhelming. I'm used to milder laurel scents. I don't like the smell of cloves, but this is too overwhelming to the point that it overwhelms and masks the bay laurel rum. Even my wife commented on the strong clove smell. Unfortunately, this aftershave balm is just not for me. If you don't like the clove smell, stay away.

Avatar Reviews  Gilbert Henry Bay Rum 1

Amazon Customer

In general, I prefer Bay Rum splash. It is clean. Over the years I have tried to use different aftershave balms without success. The usual result for me is pimples within 2 hours and a greasy feeling on my face. I'm 56, pimples don't happen to me except when I've tried balms. However, this product is different and beautiful. Smells like Bay Rum should. It soothes your skin, leaves it feeling hydrated. Perfect for the dry climate in the winter in the mountains. I apply it generously to my face and neck. It disappears within a few seconds and there is no greasy film on my face anymore. Simply clean your skin. And never a pimple. Great product. It's the little things in life that make life great. I am a customer for life. I must add that the scent fades rather quickly, which I like when I follow a male scent Aqua Di Gio

Avatar Reviews  Gilbert Henry Bay Rum 2

Bouki

Don't worry about poking your new shaved face. There is really no alcohol in the formula. What you get is an excellent laurel scent mixed in a lotion that makes your face full all day long. The scent is very pleasant, although, like almost all bay rums, it does not last longer than an hour.

Avatar Reviews  Gilbert Henry Bay Rum 3

Karl Helicher

Excellent after shave balm: very soothing and very soft for my sensitive skin. The balm has a delicious, non-overbearing, laurel scent that lasts for a few hours. I highly recommend it to all bay rum lovers, especially those with dry, easily irritated skin. Lavender aftershave balm is also excellent. Striking but not overwhelming odor. Most lavender lovers will be very satisfied. Will also be loved by many people with sensitive skin who use unscented shaving soap or cream.

102 Customer Reviews

6-GABELS Bay Rum After Shave Lotion

GABELS bay rum aftershave has that vintage 1800’s hairdressing aroma that we all love. You will even find a few bottles of these even today in a barbershop. It is one of the few laurel brands that has maintained the quality of their product over the years.

The characteristic scent of GABELS comes from laurel oil. Apart from this, it also contains bay oil, sucrose out acetate, SD-40 alcohol and food colorants. There is a noticeable touch of clove in it, but it is not at all overwhelming. The aroma is ideal for men who prefer the classic fragrance of Cologne/aftershave over the smell of modern deodorants.

I did not find any offensive ingredient on the label. Because of the alcohol content, it does burn. However, the burn is not painful. It is quite refreshing on your skin.

The balance of all ingredients in the blend is on-point. Once applied immediately after wet shaving, it soothes firms and firms your skin. It also closes the pores to minimize skin irritation caused by shavers.

Those who love masculine, mild aromas that linger on the body instead of an overwhelming scent would love this bay rum. Although the smell is not too greasy, it stays with you for 7-8 hours. What’s even better, you can re-apply it a few times if you want. It does not irritate your skin.

Because the scent is very light, you may need to use a considerable amount to achieve a powerful, long-lasting scent. The good thing is that aftershave is not expensive at all. So you don’t have to break the bank to smell like a stylish, handsome hunk.

Pros
  • In addition to the aftershave lotion, this thing can also be used as a perfume for the subtle scent.
  • You have a strong odor to contend with. It is subtle but refreshing after a smooth shave.
  • A bottle of 16 ounces is sufficient and takes a long time to start up. A worthy product for the money.
  • This aftershave cools and soothes the mess shave wounds that occur during a shaving routine.
  • Alcohol disinfects notches, cuts, and bruises but does not cause a burning sensation in users.
Cons
  • Some users may not like the light smell that GABELS has. But again, it is by no means a perfume.

Customer Images

GABELS Bay Rum After Customer Image GABELS Bay Rum After Customer Image 1

Questions & Answers

What are the ingredients? If seller sees this, please reply.

SD Alcohol 40, Water, Sucrose Octacetate, Bay Oil, FDandC Yellow No.5

How does this compare to Dominica? It is my favorite but pricey. ..

Compares very favorably with Dominica. The dominant tone appears to be clove in the Gabels product. For a while it smells very subtle and natural in the bottle and on the skin. Others claim it fades, but I don't think Bay Rum was ever intended as a cologne. Great old school finisher to shave.

Any comparison to Dominica? By far my favorite but it's pricey...

I didn't try Dominica. This one doesn't have the cool feeling I was hoping for.

Is this an aftershave lotion or a splash?

I used it as an after shave and body splash for a long time. I also applied Pinaud Clubman Bay Rum at the same time for a deeper and slightly longer scent. It is the best combination I have found so far. There are many opinions about the dozens of Bay Rums that exist. This is mine. You have to experiment until you find what you like best. I have about 10 different ones and they are all a bit different. I think the Bay Rums from years ago were a bit stronger and probably used more essential oil in the mixture. Gabels is not bad. Good luck !

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  GABELS Bay Rum After

Steve

This aftershave is true to what is being advertised. The scent is exactly on purpose. It does not smell cheap or perfume. The price depends on the quality. Don't be fooled by the large plastic bottle and the price. I recently learned that the price of a good aftershave / cologne has nothing to do with the smell or quality. The most expensive aftershaves / colognes that I have ordered lately were imitations and the smell lasted 5 minutes or less. , you could smell the chemical base and fake ingredients in it. I am surprised about this aftershave from bayrum, it is actually a good smelling and refreshing aftershave. It has burning, sharpening and tones the face after a smooth shave. The smell has not disappeared before you can leave the house. The odor is also not overwhelming, but remains in a good refreshing way. At the very reasonable price that you can pay to use a bit as a face and body splash, to wake up and freshen up. I tell you honestly, Icannot is not really saying a bad thing about this product. It also arrived in perfect condition and securely packaged ...

Avatar Reviews  GABELS Bay Rum After 1

Eastern Washington Disabled Vet

I have been looking for a bay rum that smelled of the bay rum that I had bought when I was in the army. I had bought a great bay rum while I was being deployed and I have spent most of the 20 years trying to find something in the area. I am going to place this on my normal order for shaving products.

Avatar Reviews  GABELS Bay Rum After 2

Amazon Customer

This smells slightly like cloves, which I like, but the ingredients only show bay oil. Maybe that smells like bay oil, most bay mixes have a mixture of other herbs, so I don't know. It only has a slight sting when used as an after shave. I tend to get allergic reactions - headaches - from cheap perfumes and aftershaves, but I haven't had any problems with the Gabel's It's not very strong, so you can splash it generously. The scent doesn't last long (after all, it's an after shave, not a cologne), and it's cheap, so give it a try. I will probably buy it again

Avatar Reviews  GABELS Bay Rum After 3

Patricia

My husband says this is the best Bay Rum aftershave. He says that the Bay Rum scent lasts most of the day and is better than Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum aftershave. He has used the Pinaud product for 5 years. He started with the 16 oz bottle to try it out and once he enjoyed it, he bought the 1 gallon jug !! He distributes it in a smaller glass bottle for daily use. Buying the gallon was like getting 3 16 oz bottles at normal price with the 4 bottle free.

348 Customer Reviews

7-Hurricane Series Bay Rum by St. John

I saved the best (and the most expensive) for last. My readers will let me relax (again) when I refer to this. Not that it is slightly less of a (quality) product, but it is expensive. You may have to serve more than $ 50 for one bottle. But let me tell you, it’s worth the money.

I liked how you can splash this on your face. Makers could have left with a (pump) system but decided not to. I think a 70-year-old formula is better displayed in a bottle (made by hand).

Given the heritage, I expected quality ingredients from the Hurricane series. Guess? There are some striking groups of ingredients that you will find there. First, there is a premium group of bay leaves. These things are responsible for smelling the Hurricane Series.

The scent is as you want and expect it to be. It overwhelms immediately. You can clearly see the treble of herbs and bay leaves in the scent. I go so far that this is a (sensual) fragrance, meant for men with passion and drive to achieve something.

SD-40 alcohol is a standard part of these lotions. You KNOW what alcohol is doing now, don’t you? For the record, it works as an antiseptic for the notches and cuts.

I also read about FDandR Yellow # 5, Red # 40 and Blue # 1 in the mix. These ingredients give this St. John Cologne the sparkling texture. Then you have water, laurel, and glycerin to eliminate the overwhelming side effects of the said stringent.

Prices/Images/Reviews pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 12/12/2019 09:14 AM

Glycerine also does the hydrating work. Alcohol gives users the burning feeling that they want a St. John product. Glycerin lowers the intensity. In general, the feeling remains manageable.

Pros
  • At first glance, I was addicted to the design of the bottle. It is handmade with beautiful cork on top.
  • The burn is intense; with this lotion of the Splash type, no quality has been compromised.
  • Alcohol is the driving force with its antiseptic properties and strong burning sensation.
  • I also like the strong scent of the herbs and bay leaves. Users can use the hurricane series as cologne
  • Glycerine acts as the moisturizer in the group that sinks the alcohol.
Cons
  • It is PRICE. A bottle from the hurricane series of St. John may cost you more than $ 50.

Questions & Answers

How does it compare to clubman?

Totally different universe. That is the same as comparing apples with horses. St. Johns is the best of its kind when it comes to Bay Rum.

Is this 8 ounce bottle a spray or a splash? Spray means it include the atomizer for spraying from the bottle. Splash means no spraying device.

It's the 818 splash

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Hurricane Series Bay Rum

john a.

The last word in Bay Rum colognes. Very expensive ... I almost didn't get it, but it's great!

Avatar Reviews  Hurricane Series Bay Rum 1

Amazon Customer

This is an item that is not overwhelming

Avatar Reviews  Hurricane Series Bay Rum 2

Palmman

Great product !! We were a bit disappointed with the long time it took to go from the New York City area to Huntersville North Carolina.

5 Customer Reviews

8-Grand Bay Bay Rum – The Classic, Grand Formula

Enthusiasts will remember the classic Dominica Bay Rum. It had a particularly simple approach because it was no different than aftershave. For a while, it disappeared from the shelves (to the sorrow of its fans), but don’t worry; it) returned under the name Grand Bay. (Although the terminology, especially on Amazon, becomes cumbersome. (Grand Bay Bay Rum)?)

The scent is an elegantly simple bay rum to which nothing else has been added. The ingredients are the same: water, alcohol, and Dominica Bay tree oil. The simplicity does have a downside; the odor only lasts about half an hour before it fades. Because it is primarily alcohol, it has a good dose.

If you have sensitive or dry skin, you should do this better, especially since there are no other ingredients to soften the burning of alcohol. And regardless of your skin type, a moisturizing cream is recommended after application because of your skin.

Grand Bay also offers a lime version of the same aftershave, while maintaining the elegant simplicity and only adds a scent of lime. It is a fascinating combination in itself if you like experimenting.

Pros
  • Nice traditional blend.
  • Classic laurel scent.
  • 8 oz bottle for the price of other brands gives you an ozone layer of 4.
Cons
  • Too specialized. Maybe boring for some.
  • The scent does not last too long.

Questions & Answers

How does this compare to the original dominica, or captain's choice or ogallala?

The Dominica is my favorite ... but this is very good.

What happened to the green and white label Dominica bay rum?

I do not know. I will say that I did not like this product at all. It smells more like a medicine than an after shave. The company was very nice and offered me a discount. I refused, but appreciated their offer.

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Grand Bay Bay Rum

trying to help

hmmmm .... not sure about this stuff. one star for the product and 5 stars for the seller. I have no problem with the transaction at all. As a Bay Rum fan, who has been using dominica bay rum for 15 years, I have tried Grand Bay bay rum on the advice of Antilles Trading, the company that distributes Dominica bay rum here in the United States. Apparently the company that actually produces dominica bay rum is quiet for a while. Antilles sell Grand Bay as a replacement, suggesting that it is similar. I didn't think that was the case. I feel like it smells more like hydrogen peroxide or rubbing alcohol than the rich, musky scent of the rum I've tried before. I'm not angry ... I just won't buy it again and will not really recommend it to fans of bay rum. Maybe I just got a bad party. I really don't like to leave unfavorable reviews, but I feel like I understand the type of person who would read these reviews and ... well ... I'm just trying to help. 🙂

Avatar Reviews  Grand Bay Bay Rum 1

Amazon Customer

In recent years there seems to have been an explosion of aftershaves smelling of bay rum. This one may have been around for years and I have found it now, I don't know, but when I compare it with the other brands I have used (St. John's, Royall, etc.), the scent is perfect and lasts almost right as long as the others, but at a much lower price. My only complaint is with the bottle, which has a very wide opening. This makes it a bit harder to control the amount you take out, so it goes a bit everywhere. That is a minor complaint, given the quality and price of the actual product.

Avatar Reviews  Grand Bay Bay Rum 2

Adair

I bought this because my favorite Dominica Bay Rum temporarily went out of production. (I hope it returns!) I was skeptical about Grand Bay, although it is also produced in Dominica. I don't have to worry: it comes pretty close to the Dominica brand. It might be a little stronger, a little rougher than Dominica at first sight, but it settles and spreads that great classic scent of Bay Rum. Pour some in your empty (and nicer labeled) Dominica bottle and you will hardly notice the difference.

36 Customer Reviews

9-Taylor of Old Bond Street Bay Rum

Shaving enthusiasts will no doubt know Taylor from Old Bond Street. The name alone feels British and they have been producing good quality shaving products since 1854. Their bay rum, with the slogan traditionally mixed for the discerning gentleman, continues that tradition.

There is a sharp alcohol trap above the usual, so be careful. Scented is the pure bay leaf with additions of clove and citrus, which after the application becomes comparable to a soft but spicy bay leaf. Most fade after about an hour, so you may want to carry the bottle around if you want to retain the scent. Taylor says it can be used as an aftershave or cologne.

Regarding ingredients, some caution is required. There is the expected combination of water, alcohol and essential oils, plus chemicals derived from essential oils. You don’t have to worry about that. It contains some preservatives; as always, consult your dermatologist if in doubt.

More noticeable is the lack of anything to hydrate, so users with dry and sensitive skin must be careful.

Pros
  • An old brand that is known for its quality.
  • Subtle, not overwhelming odor; also works as both cologne and aftershave.
  • Excellent alcohol trap.
  • Nice bottle.
Cons
  • Although the bottle looks good, it is actually made of plastic.
  • Very short-term odor.
  • No counterweight for the alcohol.

Questions & Answers

Does this come in a glass or plastic bottle?

Hello! Thank you for your inquiry. This comes with a plastic bottle. I hope this answers your question!

What are the ingredients?

Sorry, can no longer read the label

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Taylor of Old Bond

Jack Aubry

Awesome smell that really delivers on the feeling of rum and lime... but don’t go through a checkpoint late at night with this one, you will be doing the officers sobriety test.

Avatar Reviews  Taylor of Old Bond 1

Amazon Customer

Love love love. Old school but also great scent.

Avatar Reviews  Taylor of Old Bond 2

Scott Kappmeyer

Very happy with the purchase. Great, old fashioned scent delivered as promised.

Avatar Reviews  Taylor of Old Bond 3

neil

Good stuff.

16 Customer Reviews

Prices/Images/Reviews pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 16/12/2019 18:20 PM

10-Royall Bayrhum of Bermuda by Royall Fragrances for Men

If I were to write this article 10 or 15 years ago, this product would probably have made the list, because it was once considered one of the best bay rum aftershaves.

I remember very well that my father used this specific product when I was a child.

But although my father is still a fan of Laurel, he was forced to leave this product a few years ago and from the reviews I read, he was certainly not alone.

In short, the company, unfortunately, decided at some point to change the recipe, which resulted in a new product that is enormously inferior to what they used to make.

Not only that but unlike Gabel or Clubman-Pinaud, it’s not even cheap. So do yourself a favor and try something different.

Oh, and if you wonder about the spelling, the drink that we know and what we have loved for years because rum is actually spelled (rum)

Key Features
  • The ascent of an exquisite spicy herbaceous scent
  • The spicy scent of various herbs
  • This adventurous scent is an ideal aftershave or cologne in warm weather
  • Highly recommended by gentlemen as a tingling main wash
  • It is recommended for casual wear
  • A secretly proportioned mixture containing Bayleaf oil and the purest menthol crystals
  • The packaging for this product may differ from the image in the image above
  • This item is not for sale on Catalina Island

Questions & Answers

I bought this product in april 2017 and since i have been using the after shave i notice that is staining my sink counter top how do i clean lt ?

Is the counter top laminate, stone or Formica: usually making a thick paste of water and baking powder, making it thick and putting wet clothing on it for 15+ minutes will work. I had let this happen before. I now put all my shaving items on a small shaving towel.

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Royall Bayrhum Of Bermuda

SF

My first bottle of Royall product was purchased from Brooks Brothers in 2001 and I loved it. Later I came across a bottle at the military mail exchange and later bought something in Bermuda during a cruise. All of these products were excellent and they were all made in Bermuda - not the US like this. Since this is a review of the Bay Rum (Rhum), I will talk about this. First and foremost is the difference in odor. The Made in Bermuda version was heavier, with less alcohol odor. It was more complex. This smells like cinnamon-soaked alcohol - what happened to the laurel scent: when you poured the old stuff into your hand, it had a dark, almost tea color. This is absolutely clear. There are other differences that have nothing to do with the smell itself. The old stuff had a bay leaf, which is missing here. The bottles of Bermuda are almost completely handmade, and it shows. And finally, the original had a solid medallion cap without an insert. This new American version has a cheaper medallion cap with a white plastic cap on the inside. What kills me is that this is still not a terrible aftershave, especially for the price. That shows how absolutely amazing the old stuff was! I hope Royall gets the message about this product. If you listen, you have had the best aftershave in the world for years and your licensed American producer will kill it.

149 Customer Reviews

11-DR Harris Bay Rum

Coming from England, D.R. Harris specializes in high-end products that are perfect for men even with sensitive skin. This aftershave of laurel rum does an incredible job of softening and refreshing the skin after shaving.

D.R. Harris has a light scent, so it will not interfere with a colony if you use one. In addition, there are bonus points for the bottle with the class aspect.

Key Features
  • BAY RUM HAIR CARE: a traditional hairdressing lotion for men
  • DISCRETE FRAGRANCE: slightly perfumed with a discrete blend of citrus and herbs
  • LIGHT HOLD: use as a daily hair product for light hold and control
  • DR HARRIS and CO.: theyre a fine selection of soap, shaving creams and soaps, aftershaves and colognes, skincare products and much more, continue to appeal to everyone who appreciates quality and distinction around the world
  • MADE IN ENGLAND: imported for sale in the United States

12-St. Johns Bay Rum Cologne and Aftershave – The Classic, Traditional, and Original

When we talk about rum, all conversations eventually lead to St. John’s. The name comes from the island on which the laurel trees grew and became an important export in the 1920s.
St- Johns Bay Rum Cologne and Aftershave – The Classic, Traditional, and Original 1Since then it has grown in size. The classic bottle with its ‘fishnet’ packaging has been around since the Second World War and it makes St. John’s Bay Rum immediately recognizable to those who know it.The best way to describe the St. John formula is, ‘Blank’, It is alcohol-based, but burning is really more of a tingling sensation and it is very flexible to adjust. Fragrant, it is well balanced.The bay rum forms most of the body, but it is well mixed with the cloves, eucalyptus, cinnamon, and musk to create a nice, woody scent. However, the odor is of relatively short duration; Testimonials range from a few minutes to just over a few hours.
Pros
  • The traditional laurel scent, the classic that your father and grandfather wore.
  • The iconic bottle, instantly recognizable.
  • Subtle odor, excellently mixed, nothing overwhelming.
  • Works as an aftershave and cologne.
Cons
  • Almost too traditional; no provision for hydration.
  • Heavy on the wallet.

Product Images

St Johns Bay Rum  Image St Johns Bay Rum  Image 1

Questions & Answers

Is this a cologne or an aftershave.?

Good Day Christopher, St Johns Bay Rum is considered an Aftershave, but the scent is a great / long-lasting product, so many people also wear it as a cologne. Thank you, St Johns Fragrance Company

Are the ingredients synthetic?

NO.........

How does it compare to my favorite, dominica bay rum? it sounds like it is made of artificial ingredients, like pinaud.

I like it. It is the scent of summer for me. I love the bottle.

Is scent similar to gabels? i realize they are quite different price points. gabels is kind of heavy on clove. was curious about st. johns. thanks.

I am not familiar with Gabels, but the dominant aroma, although not overly powerful, appears to be in St John's clove.

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  St Johns Bay Rum

Mark W.

This is expensive, but if you are a Bay Rum fan, this is really great and worth every penny. I have looked at many shaving places to see if I could find it cheaper and most sites are sold out. That told me it must be worth it and it does not disappoint! And it is a very large bottle and has a beautiful outer packaging, both the size and the outer packaging also contribute to the price. Would definitely recommend this!

Avatar Reviews  St Johns Bay Rum 1

Irish

It has a nice rum flavor. You only need a touch of it. You can smell the bay and cloves. But it's a nice mix. You don't need much

Avatar Reviews  St Johns Bay Rum 2

Science Geek

Slightly refreshing great aftershave. Scents wonderfully goes light and fresh. Invigorating. Everyone loves it.

110 Customer Reviews

13-The Master Bay rum Aftershave

The Master Bay Rum is an affordable aftershave that is popular because it does not cause a burning effect on the skin. It comes first because of the perfect packaging without leaks and the mild odor.

This aftershave is generally appreciated by people who are sensitive to odor. It is an excellent product for people with sensitive skin because it does not cause irritation or redness.

Master Bay Rum is supplied in a plastic bottle with a capacity of 500 ml. It can be used for both wet and dry shaving for trimming and shaving.

If you’ve tried some aftershaves, you will undoubtedly have experienced the kick of alcohol in places where you were hard with your razor. Some aftershaves emphasize this kick to provide a fairly shocking end-of-shave experience, while others keep it low.

Master Bay Rum falls in the last camp. The alcohol provides warmth when it is applied without really poking. The scent also has some warmth, with a touch of darkness; it) s usually bay rum with a hint of cinnamon. The scent is initially sharp but soon comes in something sweet and warm.

Pros
  • The clear scent of laurel without penetrating too many other flavors.
  • The smooth feeling when applying.
  • Glycerin helps hydrate the skin.
  • Excellent price for quantity.
Cons
  • Some users prefer a stronger alcohol burning.

Questions & Answers

Does this come in a glass or plastic bottle?

I think every variety comes in plastic.

Does the Bay Rum variety have glycerin in its ingredients?

Hey Joe: No. According to the bottle you only get water, bay leaves, alcohol and the ubiquitous yellow # 5. This stuff smells great. Clean, not musky. 15oz bottle will probably last me 10 years (I don't use it every day). But it's really nice after a shower and shaving at the end of a very long day.

Which scent is closest to lagerfeld after shave lotion??????

I only tried the Master Blue, but it is an excellent product.

Is this the same scent as their ocean blue?

Don't know when I used this type of product, I preferred Bay Rhum, don't remember the blue color.

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Well Master Comb After

Andrew M

Master Blue is an old-fashioned aftershave that is usually found in the dressing room of a private club. They have it at my club and my 5-year-old thinks it's funny to splash this on his cheeks and smell like an old man. Over time it has grown on me and now I love the smell. Unless you are quite old, you probably don't use this type of aftershave, but it's a nice change of pace. Moreover, the odor never seems to wear off. After an hour of swimming I can still smell it on my fingers. Master Blue is supplied in 15 oz. bottle, that's more than enough to share. I intend to pass this on to my first-born granddaughter after he has finished graduate school.

Avatar Reviews  Well Master Comb After 1

C. Ramirez

My hairdresser uses this in my neck after she has cleaned my neck with a razor. I often smell lavender when she sprays it. I decided to try it out and it is intense when it is applied for the first time. Hence the old school. It is a tribute after a shave. The smell is wonderful.

Avatar Reviews  Well Master Comb After 2

Mr J Bob

This assessment refers only to the "FOCUS" odor. This is their version of BRUT. If you like BRUT, you'll love this. It does not take as long as the full-up BRUT as you would expect. It's a bargain brand anyway .------------------------------------------ - ------------------------------------------------ - ----------------------- This review refers only to the "CHALLENGE" fragrance. This is not an "A" list, cologne like Aramis and those expensive bands. But wear it for an everyday / non-special occasion on one of the more elegant scents. To characterize it, it has a kind of "leather" scent a la English leather, not a spicy Old Spice-like scent or a "clear" / menthol scent like Aqua Velva and its mimics And between the low end aftershaves this certain seems last longer than the others and do not expel once it dries.

Avatar Reviews  Well Master Comb After 3

MNDoT Cowboy

Wow, a bottle! I got it quite late because our uniformed federal employee system has lost it somewhere there and here. Asked for a 2nd bottle and Boom! it arrived the way it was yesterday! Recommended by a hairdresser. A little too much alcohol in it for me. Fragrence too light. Huh .....

70 Customer Reviews

14-The Bull and Bell Bay Rum Aftershave

The Bull and Bell Bay Rum is a specially designed after-shave intended to relieve burns because it does not dry out the skin.

It is ranked as the Best Bay Rum Aftershave since it is usually handmade to moisturize the skin and has a soothing effect, accompanied by a scent that lasts all day.

Made from a combination of aloe and hazel, so it is not sticky and can, therefore, be used by both beginners. It can be used by people with sensitive skin because it is flexible and does not irritate.

Key Features
  • MADE IN THE USA: Handmade by artisans using premium quality, all-natural ingredients
  • SAY GOODBYE FOR SAVING: Soothing formula ensures the best post-shave experience
  • DOES NOT DRY SKIN: Tonic carefully crafted to protect for the duration of your day
  • PERFECT FOR SENSITIVE SKIN: Made with all-natural ingredients, moisturizes, does not irritate, contains witch hazel and aloe
  • FEEL THE DIFFERENCE: No fat residue, no shaving bumps, and no skin irritation

Product Images

Bull and Bell Aftershave  Image Bull and Bell Aftershave  Image 1Bull and Bell Aftershave  Image 2Bull and Bell Aftershave  Image 3

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Bull and Bell Aftershave

LMellen

Excellent aftershave. Really nice, clean scent. The odor lasts an hour or two and then fades. Very satisfied !!

Avatar Reviews  Bull and Bell Aftershave 1

nikki

Light and pleasant essence made from clean ingredients

9 Customer Reviews

15-Bay Rum After Shave with Bay Essential Oil by Turtle Bay Premium

The stylish bottle that goes with it is enough to attract you and let you buy. Oh! And the bottle is reusable. All ingredients are natural without a pure synthetic fragrance.

The strong scent of bay leaves from the Caribbean dominates, but we can also notice a hint of naturally mixed herbs.

Prices/Images/Reviews pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 16/12/2019 16:40 PM

Upon request, this aftershave relieves the burns of the razor blades. Customer reviews show that they appreciate the packaging, but recommend pouring the splash into another bottle because the bottle is unstable. Nevertheless, it is perhaps the best bay rum aftershave for people with a pimple.

Key Features
  • Natural Bay essential oil.
  • No synthetic or fragrance oil.
  • Reusable stainless steel hip flask.
  • Most orders are shipped the same day.
  • Made in the United States, with essential oil from Dominica

Questions & Answers

What is the difference between the bay rum in the glass bottle and the bay rum in the flask. One says aftershave and the other says splash???

Sorry, I don't know the answer!

Please, name the ingredents.?

SD alcohol 40B, water, laurel essential oil, fd and c yellow no. 5

Top Customer Reviews

Avatar Reviews  Turtle Bay Premium Bay

Consumer.

The bottle is cute, and certainly reusable as a drinking bottle, but it is narrow and easy to collapse and, if it does, the opening allows much more product to escape than with a traditional bottle with a small opening. The After Shave is satisfactory.

Avatar Reviews  Turtle Bay Premium Bay 1

Luis

Bay Rum After Shave, that smells like Bay Rum After Shave from the Caribbean.

Avatar Reviews  Turtle Bay Premium Bay 2

Jonathan Sturm

Good scent that lasts for a few hours. Cool bottle container .... although I prefer a shaker for daily use.

Avatar Reviews  Turtle Bay Premium Bay 3

Fred

Great packaging, traditional scent. Love it

4 Customer Reviews

Frequently Asked Questions ِ

How Does The Bay Rum Smell?

There are many possible answers to the question, based on familiar scents, to give you an idea of the scent of bay rum.

The bay of the West Indies is related to allspice, and a scent can give a small picture of what bay rum can look like. It is also repeatedly described as the smell of Christmas, thanks to the spices. At least one woman has described it as ‘spicy cupcakes’. Another said cautiously: something that a contract killer would wear.

A woman once described it as Thanksgiving, another the most masculine Christmas cookies ever made.

We will answer that question a little differently. Think back to older times, the age of your grandfather or great-grandfather. Time for the hectic updates to the second within reach. A time of woolen suits and cigars.

Think of the ideal father. The strong man with a full beard has been carefully trimmed, who can repair his car with his bare hands and absorb all the antics of his children without ever looking.

Think of what he had to undergo to become all that, and imagine that bay rum is an ingredient in making the man.

Can I Use Aftershave As A Cologne?

Yes, you can; there is nothing fundamentally different about the two products and some manufacturers even advertise their products as aftershave and cologne. In the list above these are Taylor of Old Bond Street and St. Johns.

It’s just that aftershave is not as strong as perfume or perfume, so it won’t last that long. On the other hand, that can be an advantage: your potential partner sniffs, leans close and smells exactly what it was …

Why Does Aftershave Smell Differently In Different People?

Aftershave is applied to your body and that canvas influences the scent tones on your skin. The whole thing is really a complex interaction of your body chemistry and the make-up of the aftershave you’ve just applied. There will usually not be much difference, especially since aftershave is not as strong as perfume, but in all cases it is best to test before using it regularly, just to be sure.

Choosing The Best Bay Rum Aftershave

Some of these resort-style products can come close to the original scent, but none of them can adequately reproduce the clove, rum and cinnamon fragrance that come from a post-shave lotion.
Similarly, many aftershaves lotions replace the rum with cheaper grain alcohol.

Bay Rum Aftershave

Unfortunately, this not only eliminates the odor, but it is also much harder on the skin and can leave it with a sharp and tight feeling.

You will find that some aftershaves contain glycerin. This is a product based on vegetable oil that helps to moisturize and care for the skin, leaving it silky. If you have dry skin or just do not like the hardness of most aftershaves, then you should try to find one that contains glycerin.

If you have not tried the bay rum yet, it’s time to try it.

You will love the masculine scent.

The above products represent the Best Bay Rum Aftershave lotions; I am sure you will find one that works well for your needs.

Prices/Images/Reviews pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 20/11/2019 08:59 AM

If this article was useful for you, share it on Facebook or other social networks according to the following buttons. We would really appreciate it since we have worked very hard on this publication for you.

I have the feeling that some of your friends and family will find it useful too.

Subscribe my Newsletter for new blog posts, tips & new photos. Let's stay updated!

Prices/Images/Reviews pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 15/12/2019 20:10 PM
Share
393
658

Mohtasm Mohamed

Mohtasm is a published author and software engineer and beard care expert from the US. To date, he has helped thousands of men make their beards look better and get fatter. His work has been mentioned in countless notable publications on men's care and style and has been cited in Seeker, Wikihow, GQ, TED, and Buzzfeed.

You may also like...

1 Response

  1. February 10, 2018

    […] of brands presented on the market from which Males have to come to a decision on the best a best bay rum aftershave person for them. Over the flip aspect, there are plenty of relatively preferred manufacturers of […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *